You’ll suppose our leaders had been conscious that the very last thing Hong Kong wants in the meanwhile is one other piece of obscure, indiscriminate laws which is able to present a complete new plethora of alternatives for poisonous interactions between officers and the general public they’re presupposed to serve.
Is there, one wonders, an infectious spate of nationwide safety regulation envy? If there may be, remedy is now required within the Atmosphere and Ecology Bureau, which unveiled its newest stroke of genius at a current assembly of the legislature.
A wild boar. File photograph: Tom Grundy/HKFP.
The bureau, I don’t dispute, has an issue. Wild pigs often intrude within the city space, attracted by the mushy suburban way of life and the insecure dustbin, as many smaller animals have been earlier than them. Nevertheless a wild pig is a relatively alarming factor to search out in your housing property, and the pigs themselves are at risk from visitors.
The present coverage, inaugurated by an attention-grabbing coincidence after a wild pig bit a policeman, is to seize pigs discovered within the city space and kill them. This goes down badly with lots of people, together with me.
The bureau believes that the rationale the pigs frolic in city areas is that misguided individuals are feeding them. I don’t dispute that this takes place generally, however there are some doubts as as to if it’s actually the primary supply of the issue. Many city estates put their garbage out for assortment within the morning in plastic luggage, which aren’t a lot of a problem to a peckish porker.
An auxiliary police officer was attacked by a wild boar in November 2021. File photograph: Fb.
Certainly the Agriculture and Fisheries Division’s supposedly animal-proof litterbins usually are not a lot of a problem both. Through the interval when eating places had been pressured to shut at 6 pm many individuals picnicked in or round their automobiles within the carpark on the prime of Sui Wo Street. I’m a daily nocturnal customer right here for canine causes.
These guests had been respectable people who put their garbage in plastic luggage and put the baggage into the animal-proof bin supplied, till it overflowed and the baggage had been then stacked beside it. I suppose it took a day earlier than our native wild pig (I’ve by no means seen multiple) found this bounty and one other evening earlier than he discovered his method into the “animal-proof” bin.
After that I noticed him most nights till the eating places resumed night service. A pig with the odor of garbage in his nostrils is resourceful and decided. Little question individuals mustn’t feed them, however we appear to be choosing a straightforward goal right here which won’t remedy the issue.
Anyway, what’s the bureau’s most well-liked authorized resolution to the pig feeding drawback? Will it ban feeding wild pigs within the city space, ban feeding them elsewhere, try one thing like “feeding wild pigs in locations whereby most people is prone to be inconvenienced,” ban feeding wild pigs in any respect?
An Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Division banner at a preferred spot for feeding wild pigs. File photograph: Arthur Lo/HKFP.
Too timid, apparently. The bureau needs to ban feeding any wild animal anyplace in Hong Kong. It additionally needs to lift the utmost penalty (there may be at present a regulation in opposition to feeding monkeys in some locations) for feeding something to a yr in jail or a $100,000 high-quality.
Apparently officers imagine the current degree of fines is just too small. I not often discover myself defending native magistrates in opposition to fees of extreme leniency, however maybe the fines are small as a result of they should be. Feeding a monkey in a rustic park will not be an offence of ethical turpitude or monetary achieve and does little or no public hurt as a result of the locations the place feeding is banned are the locations the place monkeys congregate anyway. So there isn’t any apparent sufferer.
The bureau would additionally prefer to institute a system of fastened penalty tickets – on-the-spot fines, in impact — with the required high-quality to be $5,000.
I’m not positive which components of this are most objectionable. Within the first place, the making of a brand new regulation shouldn’t be a chance to blanket the territory with unwarranted prohibitions. The bureau says that the sweeping new regulation will scale back the “issue in enforcement” anticipated if the brand new regulation merely coated the issues it’s presupposed to cease. This isn’t the way in which the Rule of Legislation is meant to work.
Legislative Council. File photograph: Lea Mok/HKFP.
The brand new regulation will cowl, or threaten, a number of stuff at present thought to be innocent and completely authorized. What’s a “wild animal,” for instance? Will it cowl feral cows, feral cats, feral cats solely outdoors official feral cat colonies recognised by the Society for the Safety of Animals?
Our native minibus drivers typically eat their lunch outdoors our property and toss the odd little bit of bread to the native birds. This has allowed some residents to develop into fairly well-informed in regards to the native birdlife. We generally spot examples of the Eurasian Magpie, the Pink-whiskered Bulbul, and an attention-grabbing gray factor which some observers say is a wooden pigeon however I feel is a wild dove. Having mentioned which, the overwhelming majority of our birds are Eurasian Tree Sparrows, that are fairly cute however quite common.
Little question spokespeople will say that after all such trivial peccadilloes won’t be prosecuted, even when theoretically unlawful. However residents mustn’t should rely on the discretion of officers to maintain them out of hassle.
A authorities which needs to ban feeding pigs ought to ban feeding pigs and depart different probably extra deserving animals alone.
A wild boar. File Photograph: Arthur Lo/HKFP.
As for the on-the-spot fines, that is one other merchandise which is hardly suitable with our oft-repeated dedication to the Rule of Legislation. Residents are supposed to have the ability to go about their lives with out worrying about being immediately fined by some officious flunkey of the federal government for a minor offence.
Mounted penalty tickets are acceptable if the offence is straightforward and unlikely to be disputed, and if the high-quality is modest. The skinny finish of this wedge was after all the ticket for motoring offences, which had the benefit that anybody who was driving a automotive may very well be presumed to be an individual of means. As the concept has unfold to different areas the suitable degree of on the spot high-quality has elevated exponentially.
A high-quality of $5,000 for a lot of Hong Kongers is about half a month’s wages. In keeping with the census individuals about 10 per cent of staff earn lower than $10,000 and about 25 per cent lower than $20,000 a month. Most Social Safety recipients get lower than $5,000 a month.
A authorities banner warns that individuals could be fined for feeding wild birds. File photograph: Pallowoom14, by way of Wikicommons.
That is too heavy a penalty to be thrown about with out not less than the potential for a trial. I do know we’ve got had $5,000 on the spot fines for Covid-related offences, however that has not been a cheerful expertise. There have been far too many instances wherein the precise necessities of the offence weren’t explored in ample element, and a few wherein the one offence concerned seemed to be failure to supply to police individuals the deference to which they imagine themselves entitled.
Levelling this blunderbuss at home staff on their days off was not a great look, and the penalty appears incoherent in contrast with the case of the restaurant which entertained a party for 100 individuals, together with many bigwigs, and was fined solely $6,000.
Maybe the Atmosphere and Ecology Bureau may benefit from a phrase with our new Secretary for Justice, who appeared to confess the opposite day that it was troublesome or not possible to outline “sedition” and will not need one other authorized Rubik’s dice to play with.
Or they may speak to the Housing Authority. Amongst public housing residents the urge to undertake wild animals is definitely defined by the ban on tenants protecting canine.
|HKFP is an neutral platform & doesn’t essentially share the views of opinion writers or advertisers. HKFP presents a range of views & frequently invitations figures throughout the political spectrum to put in writing for us. Press freedom is assured beneath the Fundamental Legislation, safety regulation, Invoice of Rights and Chinese language structure. Opinion items purpose to level out errors or defects within the authorities, regulation or insurance policies, or purpose to counsel concepts or alterations by way of authorized means with out an intention of hatred, discontent or hostility in opposition to the authorities or different communities.|
SIGN UP to our mailing record
HKFP Dim Sum is a weekly e-mail abstract of our greatest content material despatched each Friday. Unsubscribe at any time. We won’t share your particulars with third events.
Success! You are on the record.
Whoops! There was an error and we could not course of your subscription. Please reload the web page and check out once more.